Bullhorn vs Manatal for 2027: Pick by Team Size and Budget
Start with the category decision
An applicant tracking system (ATS) is software that keeps open jobs, candidate records and hiring stages in one place. Bullhorn and Manatal both sell that function, but they aim it at different buyers, and that matters more than any single feature. Bullhorn's Recruitment Cloud product page describes its platform as "A platform purpose-built for enterprise recruitment firms." Manatal's homepage says its product is "Tailored for HR teams, recruitment agencies, and headhunters."
If your business places candidates with other companies, you are in the market both products serve, and the choice comes down to scale and budget. If you are a general small business that hires a few people a year for your own team, first check whether the HR or job-posting tools you already pay for cover the work. A recruiting ATS can be more system than you need.
Scope notes: I opened both vendors' pricing pages, and the plans appear under these names. Bullhorn's small-agency plans are Starter, Core, Pro and Max. Manatal's are Professional, Enterprise, Enterprise Plus and Custom. Some third-party comparison pages refer to a separate product called Bullhorn Connexys. I did not find a rename, merger or discontinuation of either product in the pages I opened, so this article covers only the plans on the two pricing pages.
Direct answer: Choose Bullhorn if you run a staffing or recruitment firm with several recruiters, need a client CRM, and can accept quote-based top tiers. Choose Manatal if you want published prices and a trial, have a small team, and can move up a tier later for automation or API access.
TL;DR: For a general small business, Manatal is the easier first test because its prices are public and it offers a trial. Bullhorn is the heavier platform, and its pricing page leaves its two highest small-agency tiers unpriced.
Key Takeaways
Bullhorn is built for staffing and recruitment firms. A general small business hiring its own staff sits outside the buyer its product page describes.
Manatal publishes prices for three paid plans and a 14-day trial, but the trial turns off job board posting and outbound email.
At four seats, Manatal's Enterprise plan on annual billing costs $1,680 a year, against $7,920 for Bullhorn's Core plan at its listed per-user monthly rate, before add-ons and tax.
Bullhorn's Pro and Max tiers have no public price, so their cost is known only from a written quote.
Manatal's Open API and its Zapier and n8n integration sit on the Enterprise Plus tier, so integration needs raise the price.
Review-site scores do not settle this comparison. The main review sites blocked access during research, and the scores in secondary sources disagree.
How we evaluated these two tools
Our method weights seven decisions a general small business actually makes. The weights are our judgment, not an industry standard, and each row names what we measured. Vendor facts come from the pages cited inline, and our analysis is labeled as analysis.
| Criterion | Weight | What we measured |
|---|---|---|
| Fit to your hiring model | 25% | Target customer each vendor states on its own pages |
| Entry cost for a four-seat team | 20% | Published seat price × 4 seats × 12 months |
| Price transparency | 15% | Share of plans with a published price; trial availability |
| Automation and integration access | 15% | Which plan unlocks workflows, API, Zapier or n8n |
| Add-on and hidden costs | 10% | Implementation terms, separately priced add-ons, quote-only tiers |
| Plan limits and known gaps | 10% | Caps on jobs and candidates; limits named by third parties |
| Switching risk | 5% | Trial terms and billing commitment |
Fit carries the most weight because a tool built for staffing firms can be the wrong purchase even when its seat price is lower. Review-site star ratings are not in the weights. I could not open the main review pages, and the figures quoted in secondary sources conflict.
Feature matrix for the plans you would actually buy
| Feature | Bullhorn small-agency plans | Manatal plans |
|---|---|---|
| Published per-user price | Starter and Core only, priced per user per month | Professional, Enterprise and Enterprise Plus, annual or monthly |
| Top tier pricing | Pro and Max: quote-based ("Talk to us") | Custom: quote-based ("On Demand") |
| Free trial | None; Bullhorn's FAQ says it does not offer one | 14 days, no credit card required |
| Implementation | Free on Starter, Core and Pro; Max scoped in the quote | Not listed as a separate fee on the pricing page |
| Workflow automation | Custom fields and workflows from Core | Workflow automations from Enterprise |
| Integrations | 300+ partner marketplace from Core | Zapier and n8n integration on Enterprise Plus |
| Open API | Public REST documentation; access terms not on the pricing page | Open API on Enterprise Plus and Custom |
| Job and candidate caps | Not stated on the small-agency pricing page | Professional: 15 jobs and 10,000 candidates; Enterprise: unlimited |
| AI features | Pro adds AI search, matching and call transcription; Max adds agentic workflows | AI candidate enrichment and recommendations on Professional; AI Interviewer as an add-on |
| Single sign-on | Not listed in the plan summaries I read | Enterprise Plus |
The matrix is built from each vendor's plan pages. Our automation layer, described in the workflow sections below, sits beside either tool and does not replace it.
What each plan costs, and what the sticker leaves out
Pricing checked November 15, 2026.
Starter and Core: $99 and $165 per user per month according to Bullhorn (2026). Both prices are listed per user per month, and the page states no billing term. The same page says onboarding and Middle Office are optional and priced separately. Bullhorn's Pro and Max plans have no published figure; its main pricing page says "Talk to us" for both, according to Bullhorn (2026).
Professional plan: $15 per user per month on annual billing according to Manatal (2026). The same page lists Enterprise at $35 on annual billing or $39 monthly, and Enterprise Plus at $55 on annual billing or $59 monthly. Custom is quote-based, and the listed prices exclude tax.
Bullhorn's Starter and Core prices are listed per user per month with no stated billing term, while Manatal's lowest figures assume annual billing. That difference matters when you line the two up, so the table below keeps the billing terms visible. ToolRadar says it last confirmed Bullhorn's prices on November 9, 2026, and it tracks 17 Bullhorn plans, according to ToolRadar (2026).
| Measure | Bullhorn | Manatal |
|---|---|---|
| Lowest published price per user per month | $99 (Starter, per user per month) | $15 (Professional, annual billing) |
| Free trial length | 0 days (no trial) | 14 days |
| Paid plans with a published price | 2 of 4 small-agency plans | 3 of 4 plans |
| Job cap on the lowest plan | Not stated | 15 jobs |
| Candidate cap on the lowest plan | Not stated | 10,000 candidates |
| Implementation fee on the entry plan | $0 (free on Starter) | Not listed on the pricing page |
Calculated annual cost for four seats, using only the published per-user prices above:
| Vendor | Plan and billing | Price per user per month | Four seats for 12 months | Math |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bullhorn | Starter, monthly rate | $99 | $4,752 | $99 × 4 × 12 |
| Bullhorn | Core, monthly rate | $165 | $7,920 | $165 × 4 × 12 |
| Bullhorn | Pro and Max | Quote-based | Quote-based | Not calculable from public pages |
| Manatal | Professional, annual billing | $15 | $720 | $15 × 4 × 12 |
| Manatal | Enterprise, annual billing | $35 | $1,680 | $35 × 4 × 12 |
| Manatal | Enterprise, monthly billing | $39 | $1,872 | $39 × 4 × 12 |
| Manatal | Enterprise Plus, annual billing | $55 | $2,640 | $55 × 4 × 12 |
| Manatal | Custom | Quote-based | Quote-based | Not calculable from public pages |
These totals exclude tax, add-ons, implementation and training, so they are a floor, not a full bill. A third-party cost guide, CostBench, says Bullhorn's add-ons can make up a significant share of total cost, and it rates its own confidence as medium, according to CostBench (2026).
Worked example (illustrative, not a customer record): an owner needs four seats for 12 months, for people who open jobs, review candidates and approve offers. On Bullhorn's Core plan that is $165 × 4 × 12 = $7,920 a year at the listed monthly rate. On Manatal's Enterprise plan it is $35 × 4 × 12 = $1,680 a year at annual billing, or $39 × 4 × 12 = $1,872 billed monthly. The gap is $7,920 − $1,680 = $6,240 a year before add-ons, implementation and tax. Enterprise is the fair comparison for Core because both include workflow automation, while the Professional plan does not. If the same owner also wants the Open API, the Enterprise Plus plan costs $55 × 4 × 12 = $2,640 a year on annual billing, $960 more than Enterprise. On the Bullhorn side, API access terms are not on the pricing page, so integration cost there needs a written quote; on the Manatal side, the tool reference for its MCP server lists names such as search_matches, and that access sits on Enterprise Plus.
Our read: the sticker gap is large, but the Bullhorn figure is a floor. Add-ons, any Pro or Max upgrade and implementation time all sit outside it, and the Manatal figure assumes annual billing.
Bullhorn: fit, limits and what to verify
Vendor data. Bullhorn's Recruitment Cloud runs on Salesforce. The product page describes it as built for enterprise recruitment firms, and it cites more than 150,000 users and four of the five largest global staffing firms as customers. Those are Bullhorn's own claims, and I could not verify them independently. The small-agency plans matter more for a smaller buyer. Core adds the 300+ partner marketplace, custom fields and workflows, LinkedIn integrations and an email sidebar. Starter and Core carry published prices; Pro and Max do not.
Best fit. Staffing and recruitment firms with several recruiters, a need for a client-side CRM, and a budget that can absorb quote-based pricing on the top tiers.
Limitations. Bullhorn offers no free trial. Pro and Max are quote-based, and add-ons are priced separately. Jarvi, a competitor's comparison page, describes a heavier interface and a longer rollout. Treat that as a claim to test in a demo, not a settled fact, according to Jarvi (2025).
Implementation. The pricing page lists implementation as free on Starter, Core and Pro. Setting up custom fields and workflows on Core is configuration work your team owns after go-live.
API. Bullhorn publishes REST API documentation. Its submission guide uses entities such as JobOrder, Candidate and JobSubmission, along with the Tearsheet field owner.id. The pricing page does not say which plan includes API access, so get that in writing before you design around it. Primary evidence: Bullhorn's REST submission guide.
Our read. Most of Bullhorn's structure, including job orders, client contacts and submissions, serves placement work. If you are not placing people with other companies, you pay for structure you will not use.
Manatal: fit, limits and what to verify
Vendor data. Manatal's pricing page lists three paid plans and a Custom plan, and it offers 14 days free with no credit card. Its homepage describes the product for HR teams, recruitment agencies and headhunters, with ATS and recruitment CRM modules, an AI Interviewer add-on and posting to more than 2,500 job channels. The pricing FAQ says full access starts after payment and account verification, which typically takes up to three business days. The homepage does not state where Manatal is headquartered or who owns it, so this article does not say either.
Best fit. Small recruitment agencies and lean HR teams. Skima, a competitor that sells complementary services, places best fit at fewer than 50 employees, which is one reviewer's view. Best-fit size: fewer than 50 employees according to Skima (2026).
Limitations. Skima lists these gaps: AI match accuracy drops for complex, specialized or senior roles; search filters cannot be saved or shared; archived candidates must be restored before they appear in search; career pages are limited to three templates; recruiter performance reporting is thin; and there is no dedicated mobile app, according to Skima (2026). The trial also turns off job board posting, email from the Manatal domain, mass emailing and automations, so it cannot test your outreach. Free trial: 14 days, no credit card required according to Manatal (2026).
Implementation. Expect a short wait of up to three business days before full access, then configuration work for pipelines, permissions and workflow automations. Workflow automations start on Enterprise, so a Professional setup has less to configure.
Integrations and API. The Open API, the MCP server, SSO and custom permissions all sit on Enterprise Plus, along with Zapier and n8n integration. Manatal's MCP documentation lists tool names such as search_matches and list_candidate_tags. Those names matter only if you plan to connect an AI client, and that connection requires the top paid tier. Primary evidence: Manatal's MCP tool reference.
Our read. Manatal fits a small team that wants published prices and a trial, and it can grow into Enterprise. Its gap is depth: recruiter reporting is thin, and the lower plans leave out workflow automations.
Where the hiring workflow breaks, and a proposed fix
The gap most small teams feel sits between a candidate applying and a recruiter replying. Neither vendor's plan table promises to close it. A configurable workflow can narrow that gap. What follows is a proposed design, not a deployed or measured one; nothing here reports a customer, a result or a live setup.
Proposed workflow 1, which US Tech Automations would configure: Trigger: a new candidate record appears in the ATS. Action: the automation reads the job the candidate applied for, checks it against the open-role list, and creates a follow-up task for the named recruiter with a draft reply. Output: a task in the recruiter's queue and one summary line for the owner. Prerequisites: read access to candidates and jobs through the ATS API. On Manatal that means the Open API, which the pricing page places on Enterprise Plus; on Bullhorn it requires written confirmation of API terms. Human review: the recruiter approves every draft before anything is sent, and a person decides who moves forward.
Proposed workflow 2: Trigger: a candidate's stage changes to interview scheduled or offer pending. Action: the automation checks that required documents are attached and that the fields the owner tracks, such as source or pay band, are filled in. Output: a gap list sent to the owner once a day, with no change to the candidate's stage. Prerequisites: a CSV export as a fallback, because a lower plan may not include API access, and a field map the owner signs off once. Human review: the owner decides on every offer, and the automation never moves a candidate forward on its own.
Build it yourself in Zapier, Make or n8n?
Many small teams stitch the same steps together by hand in Zapier, Make or n8n. Those tools can keep run histories, retries, error branches and audit evidence when you configure them. What you own is the design: observability, idempotency (so a retry does not create a duplicate candidate), escalation, access controls and ongoing maintenance when a field or endpoint changes. Manatal's Enterprise Plus plan already includes Zapier and n8n integration, so part of the DIY route comes bundled at the top tier, and Bullhorn's marketplace of 300+ partner apps starts at Core. Both reduce the build, and neither removes the design work. I did not verify Make connectors for either vendor.
A proposed US Tech Automations design would not replace those tools. For the two workflows above, it could configure a run log, a retry rule and an error branch that sends failures to a named person, plus a written owner for each field mapping. Its prerequisites match the ones listed above: API or export access, a signed-off field map, and a human approval step before any outbound message. Maintenance still applies when a vendor changes an endpoint, and US Tech Automations would configure how that change gets caught, not promise that it never happens.
Who should choose which
Use these five questions before you request a quote or start a trial:
Do you place candidates with other companies? If yes, request a Bullhorn quote and test Manatal side by side. If no, start with the HR or job-posting tools you already own.
How many seats do you need on day one? Multiply the seat price by the seats by 12, then add add-ons.
Do you need the API, Zapier or n8n? If yes, price Manatal's Enterprise Plus and get Bullhorn's API terms in writing.
Do you need a trial that tests job posting and outreach? Manatal's trial blocks both.
Can you accept a quote for the top tier? Bullhorn's Pro and Max both require one.
Who this is for
Bullhorn fits staffing and recruitment firms with several recruiters and a need for a client CRM.
Manatal fits small recruitment agencies and lean HR teams that want published prices, a trial and a path to Enterprise.
Red flags: you hire only a few times a year and have no one to run recruiting; you need a published price for Bullhorn's top tier; you need the Open API or SSO but plan to buy a lower Manatal plan.
Common mistakes
Comparing Manatal's Professional plan with Bullhorn's Core plan. Professional leaves out workflow automations.
Reading Manatal's annual prices as monthly prices. Its lower figures assume annual billing.
Budgeting the seat price alone. Add-ons, implementation and training sit outside it.
Treating a trial as a full test. Manatal's trial blocks job posting and outbound email.
Treating third-party cost ranges as vendor prices.
When NOT to use US Tech Automations. A simpler tool wins in three cases. If you hire one or two people a year, a job board's built-in applicant inbox and a shared calendar may cover the work, and a configured workflow adds upkeep you do not need. If no one on your team will own the field mappings or review the drafts, a workflow will drift out of date. If you only need to post a single role, the job board you already use is less work to set up.
Frequently asked questions
Which is cheaper for four users, Bullhorn or Manatal?
Manatal is cheaper on its published plans: four seats on Manatal's Enterprise plan with annual billing cost $1,680 a year, against $7,920 a year for Bullhorn's Core plan at its listed per-user monthly rate, before add-ons and tax.
Does either product offer a free trial?
Manatal offers a 14-day trial with no credit card required, but the trial turns off job board posting and outbound email. Bullhorn's small-agency FAQ says it does not currently offer a free trial, and a demo is offered instead.
Can I connect either tool to Zapier, Make or n8n?
Manatal includes Zapier and n8n integration on Enterprise Plus, not on the lower plans. Bullhorn's 300+ partner marketplace starts at Core, and its API access terms are not on the pricing page, so ask Bullhorn directly. I did not verify Make connectors for either product.
Do I need a recruiting tool at all for a small business?
Not always. If you hire a few people a year, start with the HR or job-posting tools you already pay for, and move to an ATS once candidates or open roles start getting lost between people.
Which plan should a small team start on?
Manatal's Professional plan at $15 per user per month on annual billing is the lowest published entry point, with caps of 15 jobs and 10,000 candidates, so choose it only if you can live without workflow automations. On Bullhorn, the Starter plan has core applicant tracking, while custom workflows and the marketplace start at Core.
Conclusion
Bullhorn and Manatal serve different buyers. A staffing firm that needs a client CRM and enterprise governance should request a Bullhorn quote for Core or higher. A small team that wants published prices and a trial should test Manatal and price the Enterprise plan, not Professional, if it needs automation. A general small business that hires its own staff should first confirm that a recruiting ATS is needed at all.
If you add an automation layer, see how US Tech Automations configures this for the prerequisites and review points listed above, and decide on the tool before you commit to the setup.
About the Author

Helping businesses leverage automation for operational efficiency.