Skip to content
AI & Automation

MyCase vs CASEpeer 2027: Which Fits Your Law Firm Best

Nov 19, 2026

The short answer for most small firms

For a small firm choosing between these two, the category decision comes first: do you need a general practice system, or one built around personal injury work? MyCase is the broader general tool. Its Basic tier already covers case and contact management, time entry, invoicing and trust accounting, and its published entry rate is the lower of the two. CASEpeer is built around personal injury workflows. Its Basic tier already includes automated statute alerts, settlement negotiation tools and medical treatment tracking, while intake management, unlimited two-way texting and extra reporting sit on its Pro tier.

Ownership is the first fact to get straight. CASEpeer has been acquired by MyCase, and CASEpeer's own announcement places the deal at MyCase's November 9, 2021 customer conference, according to CASEpeer. Rebrand: 8am, announced August 2025 according to LawNext, which reports that the parent and its products now carry the 8am name. That means MyCase now appears as 8am MyCase and CASEpeer as 8am CasePeer, and the company describes the change as "an expansion of services rather than a disruption of existing functionality." Trade press describes the products as brought under a single 8am umbrella and says the redesign is meant to grow into a fuller platform over time, according to Accounting Today. Treat the feature lists below as a snapshot, and confirm tier contents on the day you sign.

Key Takeaways

  • Pick MyCase when you want one general system for matters, billing, trust accounting and client messaging, and you do not need personal-injury tools on the base plan.

  • Pick CASEpeer when personal injury work is the core of the practice and you want statute alerts and medical tracking without buying a higher tier.

  • Compare the Pro tiers rather than the entry tiers, because intake, texting, workflow and AI features sit above the base plan on both products.

  • Plan for the top tier if you need an API, since the pages reviewed place API access on Advanced for both products.

  • Pricing is per active user, so the monthly bill scales with seats, and the published rates are a starting point rather than a final quote.

  • Re-check contents on the day you sign, because both products are mid-rebrand under 8am.

How we evaluated these tools

We weighted six criteria to match the decisions a small firm owner actually makes, then checked each vendor's public pages against them. The weights are our analysis of what matters to a buyer, not vendor data, and the item counts show how many public-page items we compared for each criterion. We did not trial either product, so nothing here describes hands-on results.

CriterionWeightPublic-page items comparedWhy it decides the choice
Published entry price per user20%2Sets the floor for seat count and shows whether a price is public at all
Contract and billing terms10%3Shows how easily a firm can change seats, pay annually or leave
Trust accounting and billing fit15%2Decides whether the core money workflow works on the base plan
Intake and client communication15%3Decides how quickly new leads get answered
Integrations and API access20%3Decides whether the firm can connect accounting tools, Zapier or custom code
Practice-area fit20%2Matters most where personal injury tools are the core of the work

The weights total 100%. We did not mark a product down for a feature missing from its base tier when a general practice would not use that feature anyway.

What each product includes

The matrix below uses tier names from each vendor's pricing page. "Not listed" means the item does not appear on the pricing page reviewed; it does not prove the product lacks the feature.

FeatureMyCaseCASEpeer
Trust accountingBasic: time entry, invoicing and trust accountingBasic: client trust tracking
Client intakePro: intake forms and legal CRMPro: client intake management
Two-way textingPro: two-way texting, chat and call logPro: unlimited two-way texting, including images
Workflow automationPro: automated workflowsNot listed on the pricing page
Personal injury toolsNot listed on the pricing pageBasic: statute alerts, settlement negotiations, medical treatment tracking
AI assistantPro: 8am IQ writing and document assistantPro: 8am IQ Legal AI
Open APIAdvanced: Open APIAdvanced: API access
ReportingBasic: customizable reportingPro: additional reports
PaymentsBasic: online payments with next-day depositsPro: integration list includes LawPay

The clearest difference is personal injury tooling on the base plan. For trust accounting, both pages name the feature without describing how reconciliation works, so ask for a live walkthrough of the reconciliation screens before you decide.

What the published prices add up to

Pricing checked November 15, 2026. MyCase's Basic, Pro and Advanced plans: $60, $120 and $150 per user monthly according to MyCase, and the same page lists $50, $100 and $130 on annual billing, a 10-day free trial with no card required, more than 70 integrations on Pro, and no long-term contract or setup fee.

CASEpeer's Basic, Pro and Advanced plans: $90, $130 and $160 per user monthly according to CASEpeer, and the page shows monthly billing only, with no long-term contract or setup fee and a rate that depends on the number of active users.

VendorPlanMonthly per userAnnual per user (paid upfront)What the tier adds
MyCaseBasic$60$50Case and contact management, time entry, invoicing, trust accounting, customizable reporting
MyCasePro$120$100Intake forms, legal CRM, two-way texting, automated workflows, integrations, AI writing assistant
MyCaseAdvanced$150$130Open API, conflict check tracking, split billing, AI case assistant
CASEpeerBasic$90Not publishedCase and contact management, statute alerts, settlement negotiations, medical treatment tracking, client trust tracking
CASEpeerPro$130Not publishedClient intake management, unlimited two-way texting, additional reports, key integrations including LawPay, 8am IQ Legal AI
CASEpeerAdvanced$160Not publishedAPI access, data sync for reporting, multi-office reporting, intake investigator portal
CASEpeerData migrationQuote-basedQuote-basedOptional service; scope set by the vendor

The counts that matter for a shortlist are below, and each figure traces to the pricing text cited above.

ItemMyCaseCASEpeer
Plans on the pricing page33
Integrations shown70+ on ProNamed list on Pro, including LawPay and QuickBooks Online
Free trial10 days, no cardNot published
API tierAdvancedAdvanced

Illustrative math, for a firm with five active users: CASEpeer's Pro tier at $130 per user monthly comes to 5 × $130 = $650 per month on monthly billing, and its Basic tier at $90 comes to 5 × $90 = $450 per month before any add-ons. For MyCase, multiply the per-user rate for the tier you need by the same five users, and remember that annual billing lowers the per-seat rate but requires paying for the year upfront. Both vendors tie the rate to active users, so a seat you add for a paralegal or a temporary staffer changes the bill, not just the headcount on a chart.

MyCase: best fit, limits and rollout

MyCase fits a small firm that wants one general system for matters, time, billing, trust accounting, documents and client messaging, and that is willing to move to the Pro tier for intake forms, texting and automated workflows. Its Basic tier includes unlimited document storage and online payments with next-day deposits, so document-heavy practices get storage on the cheapest plan. The Open API sits on Advanced only, and MyCase's support article says the firm needs technical staff who can work with the API without help from MyCase, according to MyCase.

The limits are specific. Data migration is listed as limited on Basic, the client portal is limited on Basic, and court rules calendaring requires a separate subscription. The pricing page does not list statute alerts or medical treatment tracking, so a personal injury practice would have to build those steps itself or confirm them in a demo.

Rollout starts with the 10-day free trial, which requires no credit card, and the page says cancelling within the trial means no charge. Monthly plans run month to month, annual plans are paid for the full year upfront, and previously paid fees are non-refundable. A proposed intake workflow shows where the product and an outside workflow layer would meet. Trigger: a prospect submits the intake form on the Pro tier. Action: a configured workflow checks the new contact against existing records, opens a conflict-check task for staff, and after a staff member approves, creates the matter through the API on Advanced. Output: a matter record, an assigned task for the responsible attorney, and an audit note in the workflow log. Prerequisites: the Advanced tier for API access, an admin account with Open API credentials that MyCase assigns after the firm requests access, and confirmation in the API documentation that the matter-creation step exists. Human review points: the conflict-check decision and the approval to open a matter. US Tech Automations can configure this as a proposed design; nothing here describes a live deployment.

CASEpeer: best fit, limits and rollout

CASEpeer fits a personal injury practice that wants practice-specific tools on the base plan. Its Basic tier includes automated statute alerts, settlement negotiations, medical treatment tracking and case expense tracking, and its Pro tier adds client intake management, unlimited two-way texting that accepts images, case stage screens and litigation event plans. For a firm whose intake and case-stage tracking already run on those screens, that is the strongest reason to pick it.

The limits are equally specific. The pricing page shows monthly billing only, with no annual rate. The AI features sit on Pro, and API access appears only on Advanced. Data migration is an optional service with no price shown, so it is quote-based. The pricing page offers a "Get a Demo" button and no free trial, so a demo is the only way to test the product before buying.

Rollout should start with a live demo on a real case type, not a generic walkthrough. Ask the vendor to show the statute alert and medical tracking steps on a current file, and ask for the Advanced tier's API documentation before you commit to any custom sync. Because CASEpeer now sits inside the 8am group alongside MyCase, ask the vendor to confirm in writing that the product roadmap and support model stay as described today.

Zapier, Make or a configured workflow: who owns the failures

The real alternative for many small firms is stitching a workflow together in Zapier or Make, or building it in-house. Those tools can support run histories, retries, error branches and audit evidence when they are configured, and that is a fair option for low volume with one person who owns the tool. The buyer still designs and owns observability, idempotency, escalation, access controls and maintenance. Zapier's auto-pause is a clear example: Zapier auto-pause threshold: 95% of runs over 7 days according to Zapier, which turns a Zap off when errors are not fixed at that rate. Zapier's custom error handlers allow one handler per step and a maximum of 100 steps, including those in handler paths, and Zapier sends no error notification emails when a handler runs, according to Zapier.

Make draws a different line between errors and warnings: an unhandled error stops the run and rolls back changes, while a stored incomplete execution keeps the scenario running and shows as a warning, according to Make. That split is useful, but it means someone must still clear the queue, decide whether to replay, and notice when a handler quietly absorbed a failure that matters.

A proposed billing follow-up workflow shows what a configured design would change. Trigger: an invoice in QuickBooks Online passes its due date unpaid. Action: the workflow drafts a reminder with the client's name and open balance and queues it for a staff member to approve before anything is sent. Output: an approved reminder logged to the client record, plus an exception task when a payment posts in the accounting system after the draft was created. Prerequisites: a working QuickBooks Online connection on whichever product you choose, a named owner for the reminder template, and an access review for the billing role. Human review points: the approval step, and any balance tied to trust funds, which stays with the firm's bookkeeper rather than the workflow. US Tech Automations would configure the queue, the exception task and the audit log in this design, and the difference from a DIY build is who is named as the owner of each failure path.

When NOT to use US Tech Automations. A simpler tool wins in three cases: when the built-in intake, texting and billing in MyCase or CASEpeer already cover the workflow and nothing needs to connect to an outside system; when the firm has no one to own an API credential or a connection, so the setup would decay; and when the job is one recurring reminder that a basic Zapier zap or the product's own reminders handle without an approval step.

Who should choose which

Who this is for

  • MyCase suits a general practice or mixed docket that wants one system for matters, billing and trust accounting, and can move to Pro for intake and texting. Red flags: you need statute tracking on the base plan, you need an API but will not pay for the Advanced tier, or you need a fixed data migration scope in writing, since Basic lists migration as limited.

  • CASEpeer suits a personal injury firm that wants practice-specific tools on the base plan. Red flags: you need a free trial before you buy, you need a published annual rate, or your practice is general and will not use the personal injury tools.

Firm profileLean towardReason
Personal injury firm that wants statute and medical tools on the base planCASEpeerThose tools are on the Basic tier
General practice that wants one system for billing and trust accountingMyCaseBasic covers the core money workflow and comes with a 10-day trial
Firm that wants to try before buyingMyCase10-day free trial with no card; CASEpeer lists no trial
Firm that needs an API on day oneEither, on Advanced onlyBoth reserve API access for the top tier
Firm with no one to own integrationsEither, after a live demoNeither vendor's API support is a substitute for internal ownership

Use this checklist before you sign:

  1. Write the three tasks you cannot do without, such as trust accounting, intake and statute tracking.

  2. Map each task to a tier on the pricing pages, and ignore base-tier items you do not need.

  3. Price per seat using the per-user rate and the number of active users, not headcount alone.

  4. Choose the API tier only if a named workflow needs it, since both vendors require Advanced.

  5. Run a live demo of the trust and billing steps with real records before you sign.

Glossary

  • Practice management software: A system that holds matters, contacts, time, billing and documents in one place.

  • Trust accounting: Tracking client money held in trust separately from firm money, as state rules require.

  • Per-user pricing: A monthly or annual rate multiplied by the number of active users.

  • Open API: A documented interface that lets other software read or write firm records, usually with OAuth credentials.

  • Error handler: A fallback path that runs when a workflow step fails; Zapier calls it an alternative workflow.

  • Incomplete execution: A stored, unfinished workflow run that someone must resolve in Make.

  • Two-way texting: Client messages sent and received inside the practice system's thread.

Questions buyers ask

Is CASEpeer still sold as its own product?

Yes, the pricing page still lists three named plans, and the 2025 rebrand changed the product name to 8am CasePeer rather than folding it into another product. Confirm the plan contents on the day you sign because both products are mid-rebrand.

Which entry plan costs less per user?

MyCase's Basic plan has the lower published monthly entry rate of the two, and the pricing table above has the exact figures for each tier.

Does either product offer a free trial?

MyCase lists a 10-day free trial with no credit card required, while the CASEpeer pricing page reviewed shows a demo button and no trial.

Do I need the top tier for an API?

Yes on both pages: MyCase lists its Open API as an Advanced feature, and CASEpeer lists API access on Advanced, so check current plans before you commit to a custom sync.

Can Zapier handle this instead?

For simple, low-volume flows, often yes, but Zapier and Make do not decide who owns each failure, who approves an outbound message, or who maintains the connection, so those must be assigned to a named person.

Bottom line

MyCase is the default for a general small firm that wants one system for billing, trust accounting and client messaging, with a lower published entry rate and a 10-day free trial. CASEpeer is the better pick when personal injury tools on the base plan matter more than a general toolset. Whichever you choose, compare the Pro tier against your intake and texting needs, confirm the API tier if a workflow depends on it, and run the trust and billing steps in a live session before you sign. If you want to see how US Tech Automations configures this kind of intake-to-matter workflow, see how US Tech Automations configures this, with human review points set in the design.

About the Author

Garrett Mullins
Garrett Mullins
Workflow Specialist

Helping businesses leverage automation for operational efficiency.